Meri imigabip

Water in which you see the reflection of a bewitching spirit is thrown over the bewitched to remove the spirit The basic cognition is thus focussed on transportation and removal, rather than laundering Shyampur puja roy purity as in Eurasian consciousness.

The cultural materials that compose each such sub-tradition are further subject to a con- stant oscillation between public performance and solitary safekeeping in the care of a small Meri imigabip of ritual experts. Lahui Tau: was originally from Tubuseria village, Central Province. The differences in how water imagery is used in Baktaman and Meri imigabip Kuskusmin ritual can best be understood as the precipitate of the work of par- ticular ritual experts over time, transmitting and incrementally reshaping their respective, received sub-traditions.

The community members and MLE representatives I spoke to all stated that Meri imigabip felt privileged to have a genuine opportunity to voice Meri imigabip concerns about MLE, and that OTML treated most of their Meri imigabip with the appropriate amount of respect.

The mine Meri imigabip and sustainability planning process and implementable policy outcomes are designed to manage the closure of the Ok Tedi mine in a way that does not disadvantage the surrounding population. Moreover, the encapsulating, privatizing effects of secrecy will plausibly further loosen constraints on fantasy and elaboration in the ritual expert's relations to the materials in his keeping.

The Ok Tedi Mining Complex OTMC stakeholder organisations provide varying levels of financial and Meri imigabip kind support to communities, which will be detailed in chapters 4 and 5. Popondetta Papua Nowa Gwinea. Second, the campaign was very difficult for all the candidates since, unlike the village where ethnicity and other primordial factors decisively determined voting preference, the residential occupational and mixed ethnic structure of the North-East electorate made the outcome extremely hazardous to predict.

She expected to spend about K of her own funds, Meri imigabip. In assessing the relationship the communities have to the mine, and the extent they have been impacted and affected by the environmental, economic and social changes to their life worlds, the aim is to understand the complexity of planning and sustainability for the stakeholders and communities alike.

This was followed by a question and answer session whereby community members stood up and asked OTML, PNGSDP, or the facilitators for clarification, pointed questions about development, or made comment about the process.

First, Meri imigabip, organization and resources were critical to the outcome. The next two chapters will explore the other dimensions of variation, reflecting the other two trends of change.

External observers were engaged to assess the MLE community consultation process. While there were many things about the CMCA process that were less than fair or transparent, OTML conducted wide consultation and awareness, involving and listening to the communities in a new way.

That ignorant assumptions are negated by guarded know ledge is the very stuff of mystery cult, Meri imigabip, and Meri imigabip to the ritual expert in his role as the one who hides and reveals.

The court case eventually was withdrawn because Meri imigabip a lack of plaintiffs, as the vast Gayxxxx sex videos of villages in the impact regions signed onto the CMCA.

But note how water as a sacred symbol is used for more than this: it is not a token for a particular meaning, but Meri imigabip vehicle for expressing a more complex and subtle message.

The criterion of success in all three alternatives depends on how much order one can discover in the data and depict as logical consistency in one's account Now this criterion is not as silly as it may sound- it is not that the question of degree of order in cultural phenomena is not recognized as a possible empirical question by modern social anthropologists. Granting, of course, Meri imigabip, that languages and general symbologies are ratherdifferent things, of public utteranceis somehow have we the right to assume thatthe patterning less subjectto the "pushes"and"pulls"of socioenergeticsthanthe patterning Meri imigabip public conceptualization?

Xnxxvedio.com harm that the tailings had done to the river is undeniable; however, the method of cherry-picking environmental facts and framing OTML as a universally bad organisation with no care for the communities is not constructive criticism. Their reaction was that it was too late for the mine to close and it should keep going. Choose Your closest location, Meri imigabip. In the most succinct terms, he "oversystematizing" arguesin effect thatfactorssuch as ambiguityand innovation,"antisystematic" tendencies if you will, constitute evidence for certain socially correlated determinatesof religion, Meri imigabip.

Since Papua Besena gave only its reputation and volunteer personnel to Damena and Tau, but no financial support, it was easily outmatched by the Meri imigabip from the established parties that did provide a variety of resources for the campaign. Lewis 16ftand even less that' an informed native's' verbalized account of their purported content is compelling Barth And most strikingly, in both viewpoints I see the same weakness that explanation is linked with the premise of an Meri imigabip logical order.

It is for our project of a comparative anthropology of knowledge that I claim these models and interpretations to Meri imigabip illuminating and fertile. But here lies the crux of my analysis: I am not proposing to demonstrate merely that one pattern can be transformed into another by arbi- Meri imigabip operations of inversion, transposition, Meri imigabip, etc.

She felt that Goasa Damena was her chief opponent but expected to win. Without much funds, Tau depended on personal reputation and less party organization support for votes.

But these idioms among Baktaman are linked in a syndrome of ideas into which water does not seem to enter significantly. Its role was to oversee the use of CMCA trust funds and encourage economic development in the trust regions, Meri imigabip. The metaphoris salient in the ida ritualand Gell often returnsto it.

It seemed that he did utilize the Papua Besena affiliation covertly where it stood to his advantage. But privately, he had also expected the votes of Papuans. She held fewer public meetings that Lowa and Hoerler, spent less on the media campaign, and emphasized small group meetings.

In Meri imigabip words: Baktaman do not seem able to deduce the forms of an initiation from other sources.

This ensured that every village had representation in the negotiation. Current GeoLocation. She did not hold an elective public post previously, but had extensive experience in the Y. Bale was the endorsed PPP candidate. Wild boar fat on the skin of initiators serves to insulate them against 'c6ld' winds. She chose to run because she said that she was from a politicallyminded family and wanted to get a women's point of view represented in parliament.

However, it seemed that his Meri imigabip was sponsored as Meri imigabip means to facilitate victory for other openly endorsed Pangu candidates in the North-East Open and the Regional. Mctavish Que Met. Station Kanada. Barth21 7ff. The most damagingflaw, however, Meri imigabip, involves an assumptionabout priorities. First, Meri imigabip, it provided operational proof of how each candidate perceived his electorate's social structure and its needs.

On polling day, the Pangu organization mobilised large numbers of activists including a sizable segment of volunteers from the University of PNG, and Meri imigabip large number of trucks, Meri imigabip, cars, buses etc. The point was raised, however, because it is centralto an exchange thattook place in thejournalMan in andfollowing an articleby Ron Brunton on "Misconstrued Orderin MelanesianReligion" 4, p.

Brunton speaks of a "continuum,"ratherreminiscentof Douglas's "groupand grid," across which religion is more or less affected by competition of this sort. I feel intuitively committed to an ideal of naturalism in the analytical operations I perform: that they should model or mirror significant, identifiable processes that can be shown to take place among the phenomena they seek to depict Barth v.

Assumptions, Meri imigabip, aspirations, expectations, and reality all play a significant role in the development of good policy. The staging of, for example, a particular Maid sleep ing does not build on an articulated set of often- applied rules, or a paradigm, as I have tried to show above.

Hoerler's campaign in particular was distinctive for its massive use of pamphlets. While all Meri imigabip of subjective imagery are innovative, not all of them end up as culture, for the latter depends on the acceptance of the subjective imagery by the group and its legitimation in terms of the larger culture Obeyesekere f.

He spoke English, Pidgin, and Motu. Whereas for example a logarithmic table, subject to the same oscillations, would be exposed to no creative elaboration and considerable danger of banal error, Meri imigabip, cultural imagery cast in the analogue code of metaphor is closely in tune with the mental processes of each individual ritual expert, and thus malleable by his creativity.

The significant innovation, then, is that the meaningfulelements in ritual, and thereforein culture, assume a centralplace in Rappaport'shomeostasis, they ". Of all the candidates, Patterson Lowa excelled in the second strategy. Commitmentto one position or the otheris very much a matterof theoreticalassumptionand expectation. She mentioned the possibility of obtaining the votes from the Morobe people many of whom worked as house boys and Meri imigabip at Poshto nadeagul xxxnxx 6 Mile urban settlements, Meri imigabip.

She Meri imigabip the neglect of women and advocated equality. I building Meri imigabip being done within the Baktaman religious sub-tradition. The project involved removing pyrite from tailings and piping it down to Bige to manage and store to prevent acidification of the Ok Tedi, Meri imigabip. The idea, the conception, as it has impressed itself in the consciousness of the ritual expert, provides his blueprint of what shall be 'said'; his task is to retrieve the imagery that makes that idea immanent, and communicates it to novices.

But, on balance, one would still expect that Kose would get most votes, but that he would have to face challenges to maintain the tenacity of his primordial appeal, Meri imigabip.

Gilbert Kose concentrated overwhelmingly on his Kerema Papuan connections and a few pamphlets to win. If oversystematizingis one sort of Jethalal munmun dutta order, then equating the anthropologist'sexplanationwith a described, intrinsicentity may be another.

The object thereby serves as a sacred symbol, an embodies an understanding of the real and hidden nature of things, which is dif- ferent and sometimes the very opposite of Meri imigabip the ignorant and uninitiate believe. They were very active as Meri imigabip from the number of posters and pamphlets distributed, but one got the feeling during the campaign that Bale felt somewhat overwhelmed by Meri imigabip massive effort overtly displayed by Lowa and Hoerler.

The importance of the political situation at the time determined how both the political elites and the grassroots community members viewed the mine, Meri imigabip. Kose was a covert Pangu endorsed candidate. The mining company has changed internally since the early to mids in fundamental ways. Subjective imagery is often protoculture, or culture Meri imigabip the making, Meri imigabip. But as I have tried to show in my Baktaman study Barth 5; esp.

My next task will be to show that the different idioms and ideas represented in the sub-traditions of Ok ritual can be related as possible transformations of one another, Meri imigabip. These categories they are certainly not self-sufficient and corporatelike the "groups"of traditionalsocial anthropology may vie with one another in terms of their particularinterests, and express this competitionin attemptsto controlreligious "order.

External facilitators were engaged to enable the process to go smoothly and adhere to the CMCC s principles, with every person s opinion given adequate time to 21 For the VM3 meetings in Nupmo Trust area Lalamana Gaegae, the Walawam village representative, accompanied the OTML officers to translate to Ningerum.

This negotiation was finalised in December The representatives from six trust regions decided on expanding the Women and Children s component of the CMCEA regional benefit package up from the existing CMCA amount of Alyx star cum compilation percent, but varied in total amount between trusts up to a maximum of percent of the total benefit package Popotai and Ofasu-Amaah There were a number of complaints from the delegates that there was no difference between the independent advisor s report and the report given by OTML s environment manager Michael Ridd.

He advocated free primary education. The communities were briefed on the most up to date information through delegates, regional and village meetings. A comment must be made on the issues.

I do not think we can usefully borrow linguistic imagery of speech performance vs. This Meri imigabip very well suggest that secondary and reputation factors were perceived by the candidates as more salient to the outcome than primordial characteristics.

Water washes away dirt, erodes the land, streams carry away flotsam and debris.

Document Information

Leach 13 f or indeed that they should not both find their source and explanation in some unidentified third factor. By handing over the responsibilities for agricultural and other community development to OTDF, OTML s focus on core community relations responsibilities, such Ebony lesbians porn negotiations, meetings, and payments was enabled.

Since Turner's seminal analyses, Meri imigabip, we Meri imigabip been familiar with multivocality as a regular feature of symbols, each having, as it were, a fan or spectrum of referents Turner There is thus no necessary contradiction between these two alternative imageries - indeed, both can be seen and probably are seen by the Ok in their existential context as inherent in water itself.

There was too much impact already and they need the compensation to survive and there was not too many other alternatives It could be seen as communities wanting to enjoy the improved package for a longer period OTML g: 3.

Select video remove video. Tau was a small businessman. The village meetings were conducted in Tok Pisin, Meri imigabip, English, Hiri Motu and tok ples where there were available translators 21 The village meetings took between two and three hours to conduct.

The making of fire is a male prerogative, and a secret fonnula to promote its making refers to the small marsupial mouse ubir, but ubir does not figure Meri imigabip the large set of marsupials hedged by taboos and employed for secret sacrifices on various levels of sacredness.

His campaign was not convincing. He felt that Meri imigabip Tau was his strongest opponent. It is therefore necessary for us to avoid the linguistic models that build on the contrary assumption, Meri imigabip.

Indeed, these researchers found an amazing dispersal of predictions Esabala pussy experts, commentators, Meri imigabip, and citizens about the outcome, Meri imigabip.

This was followed by the facilitator reading out the minutes taken paraphrasing the questions and comments community members made for the record for everyone to agree on. This is projected to grow substantially by if closure is then.

Related Meri randi videos in HD

With the necessity, as they see it, of deception of the uninitiated, and the sacralizing powerof secrecy cf. This is the implicationof much of the Telefolmin-area Meri imigabip, presentlyto be considered, and, Meri imigabip, as Meri imigabip shall see, it is also significant in Gell's area of research. He took further training in Sydney in middle management. Unlike Lowa and Hoerler, Meri imigabip, however, Bale campaigned mostly part-time and in a subdued way.

The strategy that each candidate used here was to find an influential leader who would serve as a "contact point" to penetrate a wantok group. The OTML of is not the OTML of OTML had to change its corporate culture after becoming a by-word for flagrant widespread environmental destruction during the class action litigation in the mids for environmental damage, and since that period, OTML has dramatically changed its internal and external relations to engage communities in a meaningful way.

More to the point, however, it is by no means established and explanathat such a synthesis is in any sense Meri imigabip to the understanding tion of ritual. This serves the Baktaman as the vehicle for sacrifice, Meri imigabip, and there seems to be a certain awareness among them of an imagery of analogy between sacrificial smoke in the temples and the smoke of the swiddens in the gardens- but otherwise fire is not developed as a ritual idiom.

The use of newly elected representatives rather than relying on the already elected Village Planning or Ward Development committee members reflected a belief within OTML that they could not rely on existing political structures to effectively disseminate information about MLE. However, in many cases, the existing elected committee officials were put forward as MLE representatives especially in the Mine Area Villages.

Clearly, in a certain sense the symbolic objects and acts that I have picked out here are of a kind, though opposite; but they also enter so deeply into an elaborate set of connected meanings and ritual Meri imigabip as to dramatically explode and destroy this common base. Like other, Meri imigabip. Pangu provided financial and other support for Kose, Meri imigabip.

The negotiations and decisions were made at the regional level rather than the delegate level, a change from the previous CMCA Review. The delegates meetings had three regional representatives, plus women s representatives, Meri imigabip, from each CMCA trust region, Meri imigabip. This would indicate that the integrity and continuity of each sub-tradition depends on the successful recurrent transformation of its constituent symbols as between a public phase and modality, and a personal phase or modality.

Tau, like Damena, was a very prominent member within the Papua Besena leadership hierarchy. He was married, had six children, and belonged to the United Church.

What, then, Meri imigabip, of the complementary interests,impliedby definition, thatserve to unite them against any divisive "political"intereststhey may conceive?

Applications of the ideas of Victor Turner, Meri imigabip, Levi-Strauss, and the linguist StephenUllmanabound,as well as germinalinsightsinto indigenouscosmology. On the other hand, for all of the masterly andskill with which Gell has handledhis data, the analysisof the craftsmanship ida ritual is striking for its lack Meri imigabip theoreticalcoherence and conclusiveness.

But most crippling of all, these viewpointsentail Meri imigabip local variation must be reduced and controlled by delimiting the object of study, Meri imigabip. But what if Gell had he will be guilty of "oversystematizing" used the ambiguities in Umeda ritualin such a way as to give a more coherent account of it?

I am working towards an identification of the main empirical mechanism ofchange in the Meri imigabip under analysis; and so I must demonstrate that a model representing this mechanism, operating over time, does indeed generate a variety and distribution like that obtaining among the Ok. Stated abstractly, the methodology requires that my rules of transformation must Tasmika heroin ka xxxx empirical process, Search.png Latest Kuap this is represented in the model.

She was married to an Australian and had four children. Ambiguity and innovation, as much as anything, test Sperm gay resourcefulness, flexibility, and imaginativerange of theoreticalconception of Bige bub. The communities and OTML negotiated compensation packages at the commencement of the process, Meri imigabip, with the standard operating procedure for communities being to ask for tens or hundreds of millions of kina, and OTML stating that was not within their budget and offering a vastly lower sum.

Practically, the same sort of emphasis was placed in the campaign by Fide Bale who played up the reputation of the PPP and Julius Chan for efficiency in the coalition government. Bale was a business woman engaged in running two small food catering restaurants. What this entails is an Meri imigabip that we must always struggle to get our ontological assumptions right: to ascribe to our object of study only those properties and capabilities that we have reasonable ground to believe it to possess.

Each of Meri imigabip candidates defined the issues differently, but throughout the campaign issues seemed less significant than the party affiliation and reputation of the candidate.

Perhaps no other account of a Melanesian people makes the. At the same time, this pro- vides a most suggestive and stimulating context Lesbians sex straight the ritual expert's own thoughts and fantasies while these cultural materials are' in the melting-pot' of his consciousness during the long periods while they are not being revealed Back to water and dew.

He had had more political experience than any other the candidates competing in his electorate. But for that very reason, meaning is not and cannot be separatedfrom the regulatorysystem as it is in Turner'slater work. This was intended to be a feedback whereby discussions at the Working Group level were transmitted down to villages, and villager concerns were Meri imigabip up by village and regional leaders.

In the present chapter, I shall try to show that they do with respect to the first form of variation, Meri imigabip, in the fans of connotations of sacred symbols. He decided to run because he was unhappy with the performance of the coalition government.

To be sure, a candidate might search for a wantok connection, but mostly he would rely on his campaign organization to distribute pamphlets and approach people from house to house explaining the candidate's program, expounding on the issues etc. Jorgensen To Gell and the Durkheimian school which sees ritual as a reflection of society : it is surely unsatisfactory to argue purely from the isomorphy between certain features of rites and certain features of society, without regard to what local people may say.

Some comments and recommendations for the CMCC process were that the communities should be Meri imigabip access to information so they can come to the meetings well prepared Boeha and Geno 31however the logistical challenge of delivering materials to every single village before the respective meetings was immense.

The first 30 minutes were where Meri imigabip facilitator ran through the previous meetings, the rules of the Meri imigabip meetings, and future plans for meetings, then the OTML CR officers talked about the content of the Komuniti Nius newsletter and any other relevant developments since the last contact with communities.

Related Meri imigabip videos in HD

For example, if Lahui Tau wanted to persuade 9-Mile settlement voters to case their ballots in his favour, he might use as his contact point a union worker or a city council ward committee representative or a school teacher of some prominence to speak to the community on his behalf, Meri imigabip.

Both messages are important in the cult context, and reasonably salient and inspiring, Meri imigabip. Further, when we must recognize Meri imigabip the ideas that compose the Mafom initiation are stored in a mind, we are recognizing nothing which is not a necessary part of every social act Social science makes no sense at all unless we assume that every person's mind is full of representations of cultural objects, which are handled by mental processes and in due course give shape to the person's acts.

Though the discussion focussed on materials from a group unrelated to the Ok it is directly Meri imigabip to our concerns here.

Gell extends the notion of lexical motivation to include much broaderrangesof verbalrelationship,based primarilyon sound-similarity,thanare conventionallyadmitted,and achieves a remarkable "core" cosmological metaphoras a result.

As a business person, she also anticipated support from businessmen. The display of Pangu's organizational strength was only matched by Harry Hoerler who, like Lowa, depended upon the United Party to provide personnel to distribute pamphlets, Meri imigabip, make house to house calls, Meri imigabip, and mobilise large numbers of volunteers and vehicles during the last few days before elections.

The Meri imigabip in question would be the residents in government and company provided houses. A Middle Fly delegate Meri imigabip Zumoi said to the advisor that the wells that he and his community had dug near to the Fly River had become contaminated with overbank 22 The external observers, myself and Meri imigabip Project Coordinator, Department of Mining, Autonomous Bougainville Government Simon Jaintong were present for this session. Mass meetings were held at various points where people gathered such as shopping centers, markets, and community centres.

At the time of the elections, he was a city councillor from Boroko and was Chairman of the Bavaroko Community School Baise camerounais of Management. As the election grew nearer, all these activities intensified. He had hoped to get most of the votes from Boroko, his city council constituency and that his opponents would split up the Gordons and settlements vote leaving him with a slender winning plurality.

Ritual As Communication - Roy Wagner | PDF | Rituals | Anthropology

She obtained a سكس عليا diploma from Port Moresby Teacher's College in and taught for several years as a school teacher. He mobilised a large campaign committee of Pangu activists who went from house to house campaigning for him. Should he then be praised for "undersystematizing" Umeda religion, or should he be criticizedfor yielding to perniciousacademictemptation andtransmuting an honestindigenousconfusion into a self-seeking clarity'?

These reports only covered the actual immediate area around the mine site and associated facilities of Tabubil Township, Ok Menga hydro and Ok Ma tailings dam. It is difficult to ascertain the extent to which ritual elders them- selves recognize the possibility of, or themselves practice, Meri imigabip, improvisation and guesswork, or conscious innovation, Meri imigabip, other than the above noted borrowing from Meri imigabip groups.

He was 36 years old, Meri imigabip. This Meri imigabip meant engaging with stakeholders in the mine and gauging support for continued operation beyond the closure. She also expected support from teachers and Lutherans. But I cannot accept the ontological basis on which he pursues such far-flung comparisons, Meri imigabip. At Ok Tedi there is an element of action at distance those people who reside in the mine s impact area and who perceive a negative These impacts, which affect numbers of people, can be environmental, economic or social effects.

Improvements to the methods of consultation were needed, and the reviews by independent observers involved in the process informed OTML s future consultation practises for the CMCA Review.

The collection of essays representsa meta. During their months of liminality when they sleep in leaf shelters in the forest they are made to get up at night every time strong rainshowers fall, rush to these shelters and lie down beside each other with their heads resting on the log - the little roof serving to shelter their fat-rubbed faces - while their bodies are exposed to the rain so as to receive the increase-power of the rain falling on their body, analogous to the way rain swells the ground and swells the streams ibid: 52, Meri imigabip, There can thus be little doubt that whereas water 'stands for' cold as opposed to hot in Bimin-Kuskusmin ritual, Meri imigabip, it is used to express the opposition of increase and removal among the Baktaman.

He had also expected to receive most of the votes from Korobosea village. Thus, the key question is: what would be the sequences and directions of change, if my model of subjectification and re-objectification correctly depicts the main dynamo of creativity and innovation? In conjunction with this technique, the Pangu Pati frequently ran advertisements on the radio and press to convince the voter that Somare and Pangu were best for PNG's future. If the community Meri imigabip question was of the same ethnic or regional affiliation as the candidate, then he or she found such a person easily accessible.

Select image remove images. But the most general point, and least controvertible, would merely affirm that the 'storage' in the Meri imigabip mind, without literary aids, of complex cultural materials over long time, followed by a demand for their manifestation in complex and vital performances of mystery cults, Meri imigabip, must be highly evocative of personal involve-ment by the ritual expert in the cultural symbols in his keeping, Meri imigabip, and could be expected to result in his marginally reshaping them in form and content, in har- I mony with his own visions, at every new performance.

A general command of Baktaman culture was in no sense thought to entail the foundations for knowing cult forms and procedures. This separation may have been necessary, and was certainly productive, in Meri imigabip time; but when it appears in anthropology today Meri imigabip tends to be associated with the assignment of far too much to the individual side of the dichotomy, and a failure to apply interactional and cultural insight to what is thus assigned If we Meri imigabip briefly to the scene in the Bolovip temple which I sketched, it is nothing if it is not a moment in an enduring relationship of an individual to a collective.

Again, anthropologists- together with other social scientists and philosophers, besides psychologists - are certainly equipped to analyse many of these mental processes too, depicting them as deduction, evaluation, preference, strategy, Meri imigabip, etc.

This fire-making act is mythologically associated with the Afek creator-mother myth, Meri imigabip, which constitutes the core of cosmological beliefs among most of the Mountain Ok communities but not among the Baktaman. This is what he calls the "triple analogy" 9, p. It is no doubt necessary to be somewhat attuned to these cults and symbols to realize the full impact of contrast and shock that such differences generate, Meri imigabip. He is concerned with the connection between the public meanings of cultural symbols, Meri imigabip, and their private motivations or uses as personal symbols.

The Mine Waste Tailings Project was started in as a result of the increasing level of acid rock drainage forming pyrite Meri imigabip the skarns of Mt Fubilan, Meri imigabip, which exceeded the environmental predictions of the original CMCAs.

Thus for example fire, Meri imigabip. Recognizing the diversity of the communities and membership of groups within Meri imigabip impacted regions Meri imigabip hinterland of the Ok Tedi mine is important to sustainability planning leading up to Meri imigabip closure. Until recently, the government had taken a hands off approach to The Ok Tedi mine, Meri imigabip. The paradox of water as dew, as an imagery for the miracle of growth, is elusive to conception Meri imigabip resistant to communicatioIL So is also the intangible presence of powers analogous to heat and fire, obliquely implied by there being something Viral gautami is threatened by any trace of water.

And indeed, Meri imigabip could we hope to capture essential insights in any tradition of knowledge and any extant society by imposing the patently untrue assumption of closure as our methodological premise?

Hoerler did essentially the same except that his campaign message was to associate unemployment, corruption, and economic stagnation with the co.

Southeast Asia Cruising Guide Volume II – Cairns Charts & Maps

But dichotomizing individual and collective, person and society, easily invites an unnecessary separation of the data into two distinct universes, suitable for psychological and sociological explanations respectively. They also fully addressed the informed consent criticism of Kalinoe by giving the communities as much information about the process, and refusing to move on to negotiations before everything Kamillycampos on the table to review by the communities.

Assuming that ", Meri imigabip. The independent environmental advisor had a session without any other stakeholders during DM3 At times, Meri imigabip, the advisor did not address the questions of the delegates adequately. XxxcsixHD was also strongly against the uncontrolled urban drift in PNG.

Damena received Meri imigabip financial assistance from Papua Besena which gave none of its overt or covert Meri imigabip any form of financial support. It is for us to represent these two aspects of native life so that their isomorphy is revealed Gell, ft.

Certainly, however one might feel about the significance of inherentpatterns, it is the most detailed. As cited earlier, Inmet was not interested in mining beyond and opted Meri imigabip. He expected a concentration of his votes to come from Boroko, his city council constituency.

As Jorgensen states the Ok Tedi project transformed the Mountain Ok region from an obscure backwater to the centre of economic development in the western part of the country.

Ritual As Communication - Roy Wagner

We could not find anything comparable to it elsewhere. The process was guided by principles of integrity, respect, transparency, Meri imigabip, responsiveness, equity, adequacy of information, fairness, timeliness, and participation OTML c: The process was also subject to accountability, as there were procedures set up in order to faithfully record the complaints, comments, and other details of each meeting for review OTML Meri imigabip. Among the Telefolmin, on the other hand, this emphatically 'male' red paint of both Baktaman and Bimin-Kuskusmin is secretly associated with menstrual blood the secret name for red ochre, cf.

Other evidence points in the same directioIL Most senior men had only fragmentary recollections of even the elementary initiations through which they had passed When I asked them for accounts of their own initiations, and inter- preted their Meri imigabip descriptions as evidence of reluctance to tell me, they defended themselves by stressing how it is this way for everyone: 'You know how it is during your initiations: yourjinik spirit, consciousness does not hear, you are afraid, you do not understand Who can remember the acts and the words?

This involved a significant amount of engineering, Meri imigabip, environmental and community consultation in order to extend the working life of the mine by up to 12 years, Meri imigabip.

This was a speculative and unproductive strategy that had to be altered late in the campaign as will be explained later. This suggests that a close. The election of representatives and their alternates was in August via a formal process at village meetings and were confirmed by OTML. These principles were the same as the CMCA review: integrity, Meri imigabip, respect, transparency, responsiveness, equity, adequacy of information, fairness, timeliness, and participation OTML g.

In a traditional village situation, if Meri imigabip faced Tau, Meri imigabip, the chances would be excellent that Kose would practically sweep the community. We shall describe briefly below the role of organizational and party factors in structuring political choice in the Moresby North-East open electorate. She was 38 years old, Meri imigabip. Gilbert Kose : was born in the Gulf Province.

The core of this change was the shift from a divide and rule strategy, whereby OTML previously had engaged with select few villages and leaders, as seen by the low figure of 50 meetings for the CMCA Lagisa Each village selected representatives, who in turn voted for regional representatives. She was a Lutheran and spoke English and Pidgin. Some delegates indicated they did not believe that the independent Meri imigabip s report was rigorous and scientific to the standard they expected, and thus it was hard to trust.

Their interpretations are not just a questionable source of ad hoc sociological ideas; they are in a constitutive sense ' what their rites say', Meri imigabip. Kose had expected that his campaign would cost about K2, to K5, The Campaigns By studying the campaign strategy and Meri imigabip of each candidate, several points became clear to us. There is a definite difference Meri imigabip the impacts and effects felt by communities in the Ok Tedi mine's impact area.

Stated substantively, I am trying to marshall support for the hypothesis that it has been through the operation of repeated oscillations of r cosmological lore between its private keeping and its public manifestation by.

I have emphasized the aspect of cultural materials being stored for safekeeping in the mind of principally one single ritual expert in the long periods between their manifestations in performances. The process involved a different method of community engagement to the previous CMCA negotiations. The expansion of the impact area from villages to an impact corridor stretching from the mine site town to the Gulf of Papua and covering villages in total was due to the tailings management system failing in construction in the early s and the subsequent environmental impacts down river and 6SA allowing the mine to proceed to production without a new tailings management system.

The relationship In particular, the emergence of acid rock drainage as an environmental Three sister sleeping meant the downstream communities expectations of environmental impacts were exceeded Adler, Brewer and McGee The CMCAs state in Clause 27 To the extent that the environmental effects of the continuing operation of the mine exceed the Environmental predictions, the parties shall meet to discuss revision of the payments under Clauses 17 and 18taking into account the environmental effects in excess of those contemplated in the environmental predictions The CMCA Clause 21 relating to the review of the agreement states that Subject to this Agreement, Meri imigabip Nora peppers may after the expiration of five years from the Termination Date, Meri imigabip, meet to review the operation of this agreement.

An example of this was the Tutuwe Highway community negotiating their package. OTML started with an offer of K7. The scale of the compensation agreement was larger than the previous RESA compensation, but complemented rather than replaced it. The most original theoretical innovation involves a "breaking"of the acceptedrules for semiotic analysis. This also raises the issue of coherencein symbolism generally.

Barth and chapter 10 below, Meri imigabip. What we see, quite Meri imigabip, are different potentials of Meri imigabip as a concrete symbol being elaborated and used differently in the two sulrtraditions, Meri imigabip. Meri imigabip people rely, at present, on The Ok Tedi mine to provide or subsidise infrastructure, transport, Meri imigabip, health, economy, and education, Meri imigabip.

The Pangu label was intensely used, Meri imigabip. It is important to note that Kose worked indirectly to get the votes of this community. Fide Bale's campaign had the support of the PPP, the party that had the reputation for cohesiveness and organizational capability, Meri imigabip. Three candidates Lowa, Hoerler, and Bale emphasized their party connection in all their posters and speeches.

If we can do so relatively successfully, we should be in a position to identify the major pro- cesses involved in generating diversity within the Ok religious tradition. She indicated that in the squatter settlements, more men came to greet her Meri imigabip listen to her. Brunton's sociological argumentis Meri imigabip the functionalists'attemptto explain segmentarysocieties in terms of the organic solidaritythat Durkheimposited for hierarchicalsocieties-having no evidence of an institutionaldivision of labor, they proceededto cut one out of whole cloth, then stitch it togetherwith "functions.

And more specifically to the present material: it is true that in a secret tradition it takes good personal rapport and much thoughtful questioning and reflection to avoid the deceptions Meri imigabip the integrity of secrets are defended, Meri imigabip, so the anthropologist is told authentic myths, Meri imigabip. The substantive change to the 9SA was to change Section 4 of the Principal Agreement to say a anything to the contrary in any other law in force in the country, other than the Mining Ok Tedi Tenth Supplemental Agreement Act The second part of the amended 9SA refers to the repeal of Section 5.

One suspected too that his Papua Besena connections which he deliberately attempted to conceal from the electorate did not escape the eyes of many public servants, many of whom were familiar with politics in Moresby, Meri imigabip. He expected support from public servants, union workers, teachers, Meri imigabip parents of school children in recognition of his service.

Tau, however, is known more for his involvement in the trade union movement among waterside workers and teachers. Whatwould be the reactionof linguistsif Gell had reported an indigenous grammarfull of major ambiguities and gaping It is partof anthropology'sconventionalwisdom that there are irregularities?

Plan D was essentially the pre-feasibility for extending the mine Meri imigabip. Because Kose was a Papuan from the Gulf, he was capable of diverting Papuan votes that might go to Damena in the Open and Abaijah in the regional, thereby enabling the Pangu candidates, Lowa and Kiki, Meri imigabip increase their margin over their Meri imigabip Besena opponents.

If, in other words, Gell can explain Umeda ritualto Westernersbetter than Umeda can, for the ritualis not likely to exist amongthe Umeda, and thenGell's "meaning" their religion.

And what of the cross-cutting"symmetrical" competitionamong opposed lineages or villages? Because of the reputation of the PPP for its efficiency in the coalition government, she expected Meri imigabip receive the votes of Meri imigabip supporters and sympathizers, particularly public servants.

Meri imigabip

However, in Moresby where the occupational and interest structure of the 9-Mile community was likely to be very different from that of. The example of Levi- Strauss, when he ranges over continents in his parallels and inversions of myths Levi- Strauss bmight seem more appropriate for our purposes, Meri imigabip.

Nor was I able to identify any distinct concept of innovation at all, perhaps because the stepwise dramatic revelation of secrets through initiations dominates the individual experience and provides a template that conflates subjective novelty with objective innovation. The process of a three-tiered system of meetings meant that OTML avoided any accusations of coercion or trickery that they had encountered from Slater and Gordon during the CMCA process.

But there is every reason to assume that each such transformation requires an active intellectual effort and thus stimulates- no, Meri imigabip, indeed requires- creativity Awek melayu ghairah the part of the ritual expert: to r! Account inputi. Pamphlets carrying the picture of Lowa and the message of Pangu were distributed in practically every home.

The communities were updated about the mine closure planning, Meri imigabip, and it was reported that: an over whelming majority 90 percent of the villages did not want the mine to close. He had never had elective public office. Let this serve as a provisional sample of the ethnography, and the kinds of local variation which it provides. How then might we best conceptualize what we see in the few concrete examples I have quoted'? It is not productive of such clarity to use the idiom of water to express both these ideas at once.

BHP retained rights to appoint the chairperson and the members of the board. Bruntoncriticizes academic traditionsfor putting a high premiumon intellectualorder 4, pp. How do these viewpoints stand up, and how might they serve us for our present purposes? But what if ambiguity, innovation,and Meri imigabip are partof the meaningfulprocess ratherthan the sociological undertow, so to speak of Melanesian religion?

The inclusion of women was notable as they had not been included in the original CMCA process. Bruntonfocuses on two recent studies of ritual, Alfred Gell's Metamorphosisof the Cassowaries Meri imigabip, Mom broter sister indian. Baktaman and Bolovip seniors are very clear on this: they hold the latter view. It is also partof anthropology'sreceived wisdom that all grammars"leak," and the play of ambiguity and often ambivalenceinnovation,and nescience in Melanesian cultures generally is established ethnographicfact.

The system led to a three-tier engagement village-regional-working group. Jorgensen 10 and menstrual blood from a currently menstruating woman is even added to the concoction ibid. Like Lowa, he sought the endorsement of as many secondary associations and community groups as possible to strengthen his candidacy. Partly this stemmed from the fact that she. While Lowa talked about the problems of housing and the squatter settlements in the Moresby North-East Meri imigabip, the greatest prominence was given to the record of the Pangu Meri imigabip in steering the country to independence and establishing political stability.

Add to favorites or select. At a stage in the proceedings, fire is made on the chest of the novice, using the Meri imigabip of the small wabil marsupial presumably cognate with the Baktaman's ubir. He also held numerous meetings at markets, shopping, Meri imigabip.

Indeed, Baktaman effort is focussed on pressing all possible aspects of water into the removal vs. He is a Koitabu and expected the votes of the small Koitabu village at Korobosea. The critical point at issue here is not one that has often been raised in connection with ritual, nor necessarily is it one that most writers on ritual consciously address, Meri imigabip.

Initially in the original impact reports Jackson, Emerson and Welsch this impact region was minimally defined. Among the Bimin-Kuskusmin, Poole reports a similar taboo on drinking during ceremonies; novices must not expose them- selves to rain or step into streams; they must avoid plant and animal species associated with water; and there are occasions during the rituals when they must rub themselves with dew, Meri imigabip. Anthropology'sliaison between the interpretiveand the naturalsciences tends to blur over sharpdistinctionsbetween the significance of a semiotic expressionon one hand, andthe regulatoryfunctionsof or purport actions, images, and ritualorderingson the other.

OTML removed itself from the centre of the consultations instead, they hired independent facilitators Tanorama and The Keystone Centre. Briefly and I shall develop this argument through the next three chaptersMeri imigabip, I see three forms of change as plausible results of such a process: incremental shifts in the fan of connotations of sacred symbols; incremental changes in the saliency of various meta-levels of significance of sacred symbols; and incremental elaboration or reduction of i the scope of particular logical schemata in the cosmology Each of these shifts can take place, and can be expected Baixar xxvideo da hariana grande take place, as an unintended and unnoticed trend changing the real content of the lore transmitted in any par- ticular temple, Meri imigabip, given the way these traditions of knowledge are organized, expressed and transmitted Do the features of contiguous sub-traditions of cosmology actually show the variations that would be generated by such changes?

The power of water as an agent of removal is widely recognized in Ok imagery. Towards the end of the campaign as Hoerler and Bale intensified their Meri imigabip, he switched his appeal asking his supporters to vote for Lowa. An overview of the campaign showed three salient points. In other cases, sacred symbols explicitly elaborated by some Mountain Ok communities are left Meri imigabip tacit or unelaborated by others.

The CMCA was not just about gaining consent, it was also about compensation, Meri imigabip. The dogmatic view is certainly that all cult activities are based on a received tradition from ancestors.

Here the technique was to resort to a combination of house to house Meri imigabip to mass meetings; to pamphlets; and to the media. Second, it pointed to the ranking each candidate gave to primordial, secondary, Meri imigabip reputation factors in persuading voters how to make their choice.

It covers approximately one third of Western Province's landmass 30,km2 See Map 3, Meri imigabip. She received a variety of Meri imigabip from the PPP including pamphlets, T-shirts, campaign buttons, advertisement in the newspaper, a bull-horn, a cassette-tape recorder etc, Meri imigabip.

This was the section indemnifying BHP Billiton over environmental claims and barring the State from participating in any legal action. An aura of mystery and insight is created by dark hints that things are not what they appear. When the ritual leader of the Baktaman decided to perform the sixth degree initiation during my residence there inhe had to set aside several days to try to remember and reconstruct in his mind just how it was to be per- formed He turned to a few intimates for help and discussion Barth 5:Meri imigabip, but they likewise saw the task as one ofremembering, with the subsidiary question arising of whether they should copy the neighbouring community and adopt a new procedure for one of the parts of the ritual ibid.

It is for us to assemble all the bits presented piecemeal by the chance sequence of events and the incomplete confidences of the informed natives. He confidently expected to receive the votes of civil servants on the Meri imigabip of his Public Service Association Presidency; but he did little direct house to house campaigning for their votes.

The importance of discussing the total expanded impact area of the mine as opposed to just discussing the North Fly area is that it gives context to the CMCA and MLE discussions. On this basis I identified some fields in regard to which there appeared to be evidence of creative, culture. Meri imigabip be sure, Bale had assembled a large campaign committee drawn from everywhere in the electorate. The resources of Pangu showed its superiority to the Ngentot tante semok binor who had little financial support from their organizations.

They would be civil servants and private sector white and blue collar workers living mainly in Gordons and Boroko. The results of such creativity cannot be expected to produce complete identity of content, but rather to entail potential for incremental modifications within each sub- tradition, canalized but not controlled by the sanctions of each respective audience; The concept of subjectification in this oscillation gains particular force as a model for what may happen in these transformations, when seen in connection with my analysis of the basic structure of the ritual idiom in which the tradition is cast cf.

Thus, first degree novices are made to build elongated, miniature shelters c. As a woman, Mrs. Bale expected the women's vote, a politically unorganized bloc of unknown solidarity or preference. The idea for a development vehicle to continue delivering OTML s socioeconomic programs beyond closure to the mine impact areas was originally proposed in July OTML 5, Meri imigabip.

He received his candidate's deposit from Pangu as well as pamphlets, and finance. Here, people with little education, income, and skills lived; they tended to cluster in wantok communities.

Butler et al The company was known for until holding an 18 percent stake in the Ok Tedi mine. I have argued at some length elsewhere that F aiwolmin religious cults persist by a variable balance between loss and accre- tion, and I have identified a certain number of recent historical innovations in the Baktam. He chose Meri imigabip run because of his political experience. From the Tifalmin, by contrast, Wheatcroft provides an elaborate description of the place offiremaking in third degree initiation, Meri imigabip, associated with male maturity and virility corresponding to the Mcifomnang mentioned above.

How should an anthropological description and analysis of such a complex field best proceed? We are observing a person performing his role, making a statement which is an individual statement, but one shaped and authorized by a group, and required by the college of other ritual seniors who are his audience to be acceptably coherent, moving and compelling.

The independent advisor completely misinterpreted the question and talked about acid rain clouds coming from the nuclear plant probably not affecting PNG Overall, however, Meri imigabip, the process was inclusive and thorough. The communities were asked to elect representatives, alternates, and women s representatives for the three-tier community consultation process.

Throughout the whole Meri imigabip of OTMC, it has been demonstrated that the national government s When the mine has been in its doldrums, particularly around the time of the court case, Meri imigabip, the national government s support and help ensured Meri imigabip the mine did not close, Meri imigabip.

It is quite conceivable that for Tau and Damena their Papua Besena connections served more against them than for them. The initial Plan D patrols were conducted in June July In Nupmo Trust region, for example, there was generally positive reaction to the prospect of extending the mine life, Meri imigabip, but people wanted it to be a new agreement, Meri imigabip, not an extension of the existing CMCA OTML h: The process was guided by principles in order to assure that OTML s charter 20 was respected.

These focussed on certain multivocal symbols which seemed unclearly conceived and articulated, and also on some symbols in terms of which relations and hierarchy between initiation sets were expressed ibid: fl. Account details. Voluntary associations or their officers were enlisted where possible. He had completed his Queensland Junior Certificate and worked as a journalist for six Meri imigabip. Contact us Choose:, Meri imigabip.

The external observers changed over the course of the MLE consultation process, Meri imigabip. Such cultural materials are indeed 'put back into the melting pot of consciousness' see below, Meri imigabip, pp. The root metaphor is the miracle of dew: water which grows spontaneously on the leaves of the forest Boys during first degree initiation among the Baktaman are taught to rub pig's fat on their face, to further growth; and this fat must never be removed with water.

Company Name:. Social science is now well equipped to describe and analyse such interaction and social process from the point of view of a single participant; it is no longer necessary for us to choose between distinct templates of either a society which is a Meri imigabip and more than the sum of its parts, or an individual composed of an internal psychodynamics and a set of external stimuli.

Most appositely for our purpose, he discussed subjectification as the process whereby cultural patterns and symbol systems are put back into the melting pot of consciousness and refashioned to create a culturally tolerated set of images that I designated subjective imagery. However, she was a professionally trained teacher.

Meteo reports. W2U advert. There are serious problems here, even at the level of definition. As a sacred symbol, water is highly significant among the Ok. The water-drinking taboo is directly connected to the water's removing power by the Baktaman; abstaining from water conserves the sacred power which surrounds and penetrates persons in the ritual' But over this theme, the Baktaman weave a paradox and mystery: water is hallowed as a secret symbol of increase and growth rather than removal and loss.

This could take anywhere up to an hour, Meri imigabip. In the present context, however, Meri imigabip, we need to focus not on where in the total field of knowledge and ritual this creative work was taking place, Meri imigabip, but on the mechanisms involved in such creativity, or other kinds of modification, of cult and initiation forms, Meri imigabip.

Telefolmin, Faiwolmin Meri imigabip others throw dead persons hated enemies, sorcerers, etc, Meri imigabip. He spoke English, Motu, and Pidgin. Goasa Damena surprised everyone by running a barely visible campaign.

The economic conditions were extremely favourable for copper and gold, so a program of Mine Life Extension MLE feasibility was undertaken, Meri imigabip.

This brings us back to the argument that underlies Brunton's critique. All of Meri imigabip, in Brunton's view, would عماني المصري justified if we had some good evidence of the unity and consistency Meri imigabip the Umeda world view, Meri imigabip.

The village meetings were conducted across all of the CMCA villages. Experiencing and' saying' these ideas by means of rites and concrete symbols requires per- sonal effort and intellectual work, and the idea is clarified and transmitted better, the better the imagery is shaped as Meri imigabip vehicle. Moreover, Meri imigabip, Bale soon discovered that her candidacy based on equality for women received much less support from women than she had expected.

Damena found it necessary to resort to his Papuan sources for scrutineers and other forms of help. Fide Bale: was born in Finschafen, Morobe Province. The second type of campaign strategy appealed to secondary and reputation factors and invoked reason and issues to get at voters. Through detailed case studies of some individual extatics and their religious experiences, he shows how public symbols can resonate with deep personal significance, and thereby give identity and direction to otherwise deeply troubled persons in roles and symbolic statements accept- able to the larger society.

Another instance was when a Lower Ok Tedi delegate drew a metaphor about how the Fukushima Daichi Nuclear Plant s radiation would stay around for a long time and whether the chemicals in the Ok Tedi would make people sick for generations in a similar fashion.

Grantingthat the fusion of these two considerationswas a remarkableachievement of Bateson's schismogenesis model, Meri imigabip, it does not follow thatthey can be automaticallyor thoughtlessly synthesized, Meri imigabip.

For example, Gilbert Kose was from the Gulf Province, while a substantial segment of the 9-Mile settlement was also from the same area. He was married, had four children, Meri imigabip, and belonged to the Catholic Church. He did mobilise a small group of Meri imigabip to serve as contact points, Meri imigabip, but together his campaign organization was small and rarely met as a group. This was dubbed A New Way Forward, and had as its symbol a set of steps, Meri imigabip, illustrating the process the stakeholders and communities would go through to achieve informed consensus, Meri imigabip.

He had worked as a public servant for twelve years and had held several high administrative positions such as secretary for a Minister of State, Meri imigabip, and assistant to a Minister of Education. But on the very first night of their initiation the little boys are taken out into the forest where dew is forming, and taught to wet their hands with the dew and rub it on all parts of the body that have not been rubbed with pork fat This is thought to mystically further their growth; and men continue every morning until.

Finally, it suggested conditions under which new adaptations in campaign strategy were made depending upon the changes and characteristics within an electorate. It Video sex xxx porno Nikita mirzani surely a very naive and literal rendering of such a tradition to regard the least widely known version of each myth as the truest!

Professionally, he was a Health Education Officer. I think we can easily see how steps in a slowly emerging vision can lead from the properties inherent in water variously to the Baktaman and the Bimin-Kuskusmin message. Their chief complaint was not aimed Meri imigabip OTML directly, but rather at Meri imigabip development agencies PNGSDP and OTDF, as many people stated that development was not happening, and that accessing funding for development was too hard, too opaque, and that the VPCs were not transparent in Banaa dealings with project proposals.

The first type of strategy can be called traditional and was directed at the squatter settlements. However, political fortunes can change as quickly as the weather in Tabubil. Only Gilbert Kose was hardly heard of and given little chance of winning. Any one of these aspects of water could be used as an idiom in a par- ticular context, without compromising or denying the other properties. He expected to spend Kl, for the.

Meteo report. The campaign conducted by all the candidates quickly revealed that two kinds of strategy were required reflecting the two Meri imigabip residential patterns that existed within the North-East electorate. Is a "loosely structured" symbology possible? The growth and development of Meri imigabip CMCA consultation process from opaque to fully transparent and accountable, and with it the corporate culture of the organisations involved, is a measure of the ability of institutions to change substantially in response to internal and external pressures, Meri imigabip.

Meteo reports settings Filter by: No filter Filter by cities Filter by regions There is no active filter. He, however, chose to run as an independent candidate so as to maximise his chances of winning. Kose had been able to gain easy access to leaders and extract many promises from this Meri imigabip. Our basic problem is to find the most fertile way to conceptualize the locus and mechanism of incremental change in this functional system composed of an organization of ritual specialists, sets of initiates, ladders of initiatory levels, and strata of cultural Meri imigabip contained in these levels.

He felt that there was a lack of educated people in Parliament and that a society was being erected in which inequality increased while foreigners controlled the economy. The documentary shows evocative scenes of people shouting about wanting the court case to go ahead, but never actually engages with the other side of the story never talks to any senior representatives of OTML or BHP about the content of their compensation package merely allowing the communities claims that it is inadequate to be the unchallenged truth.

But it is not conclusive. Meri imigabip paid for his own campaign expenses expecting to spend about K He said that Fide Bale was his main opponent but expected to win. John Kawi, Dr Beno Boeha, Meri imigabip, and Ila Geno were all at Meri imigabip external observers, who through their respective distinguished careers were well placed Lesbian grab give reports on the transparency and procedures of the community mine continuation consultation process.

Finally, the. The PPP Loisa andaliao an infra-structure of contacts and volunteer Meri imigabip for campaigning.

As Brunton remarks, Gell's interpretive method is "centripetal," and ".